May 13th, 2020

Members Click Here Membership Email Join Us!

RefPack033: The Secret Origins of Cartooning

Reference Pack

REFPACK 033
Download Page
Members Only Download

Every other month, members of Animation Resources are given access to an exclusive Members Only Reference Pack. These downloadable files are high resolution e-books on a variety of educational subjects and rare cartoons from the collection of Animation Resources in DVD quality. Our current Reference Pack has just been released. If you are a member, click through the link to access the MEMBERS ONLY DOWNLOAD PAGE. If you aren’t a member yet, please JOIN ANIMATION RESOURCES. It’s well worth it.


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


Hans Holbein Dance of Death

TAKING A BROADER VIEW OF THE HISTORY OF ANIMATION

When the history of animation is taught in schools, the course generally starts with Emile Cohl and Winsor McCay and moves on from there. But animation is just a subset of a larger subject- cartooning, and the history of cartooning goes back hundreds of years.

The definition of the word “cartoon” originally meant a preliminary sketch for a painting. But with the introduction of printing around 1300, the purpose of cartoons began to change and evolve into what we know it to be today. When trying to trace the origins of cartooning, it is important to define what cartooning is. The basic elements of a cartoon are…

  • LINE DRAWING: The essence of a cartoon is the stylistic refinement of an image into a simplified rendering in line.
  • CARICATURE: Cartoons employ exaggeration, which illuminates truth and crystalizes a specific point of view.
  • SUBJECT MATTER: Usually, the subject matter of cartoons are humor, political or social satire, adventure or fantasy.
  • ECONOMICS: Cartoons are usually mass-produced using an inexpensive, ephemeral medium aimed at an audience of common people.

Some of these elements may exist more or less in specific types of cartooning; but in general, these are the definining elements.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Knight

GROUND ZERO FOR THE ART OF CARTOONING: THE WOODCUT

In earlier times, a line sketch existed primarily as a preliminary design. It wasn’t valued as a work of art in itself. It was simply a by-product from the creation of a bigger work. Because they weren’t seen as important, very few line drawings before 1300 have survived. But with the introduction of printing, all that changed.

In the mid-15th century in Europe, woodblock printing began to emerge. The carving of the blocks didn’t allow for gray scale rendering, and because the wood and paper surfaces were uneven, solid areas of black did not print cleanly. The woodblock engravers developed a system of line hatching to both simplify and stylize images, and to indicate gray tones. As time went by, the hatching began to wrap around the volumes of the subjects, defining mass. By the beginning of the 14th century, inexpensive woodblock books were being produced, aimed at an audience of common people, both literate and semi-literate.

Around this time, Albrecht Dürer began producing elaborate woodblock prints depicting the Apocalypse, famous Saints and other religious themes. These prints were mass-produced and sold as souvenirs to pilgrims at religious shrines. Printed on cheap paper, these were among the first “broadsheets”, the publication format that spawned both newspapers and comics. Dürer’s prints were so popular, they were widely duplicated and published without his permission. He began putting a “trade mark” consisting of his initials on his own prints to identify them, but crafty plagiarists just duplicated his mark along with the image. Finally, Dürer petitioned the court in Nuremberg and in Venice and succeeded in getting an injunction against the copiers. This was the birth of our modern day copyright law.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Pope


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


HANS HOLBEIN AND HIS DANCE OF DEATH

There are many questions about the origin of Hans Holbein’s “Dance of Death”. Experts estimate that they were produced in Basel, Switzerland sometime between 1522 and 1526. They were uncommissioned, so Holbein was free to express his personal point of view about the subject matter. The engraving was done by Hans Lüzelburger Formschneider in Basel, under the supervision of Holbein. The political, religious and social criticism embedded in these woodcuts probably prevented their publication for over a decade.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Friar

Holbein evidently was highly critical of Church officials, from the Pope all the way down to the local monk and nun. The Pope is depicted with the Emperor kissing his feet, while devils hover around him. The Friar is dragged away by death, clutching his donation box, and the Nun is more interested in a handsome troubadour than she is with her prayers.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Nun

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The King

Political figures don’t escape Holbein’s critical eye either. The King is a caricature of Francis the First of France. The Judge is about to pass judgement on a poor man in favor of a rich man, and the Lawyer receives cash bribes on the street. A devil perches on the shoulder of the Senator who has turned his back on the poor. The Knight (higher up on this page) is foiled by his own vanity only to be impaled on his own lance, and the Soldier is in a fight for his own life with Death, but doesn’t stand a chance even with the best armor.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Lawyer

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Gambler

Moral infractions are criticized harshly. Death and the Devil have a tug of war over the Gambler as another card player deftly scoops the money off the table, a lone woman is rescued from the Robber by Death’s interception, and the Drunkard is served by Death as his companions cavort with women and throw up all over the ground.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Drunkard

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Old Woman

Most telling is the way Holbein depicts common people. The Old Woman is welcomed by Death as another spirit plays music to lead her on her journey, Death aids the Farmer at his plow., and Death gently leads the Old Man into an open grave as he plays music on a dulcimer for him. It’s clear on which side Holbein’s allegiances lay.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Farmer

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
The Old Man

HOLBEIN’S MASTERPIECE AS AN EARLY EXAMPLE OF CARTOONING

Now that you know a little bit about these woodcuts, let’s apply it to the four basic elements of cartooning…

  • LINE DRAWING: The medium of woodblock printing prompted the development of stylized representation of image and mass in line.
  • CARICATURE: Holbein expresses his pointed opinions about religious, political and social issues by exaggerating and criticizing them through his drawings. He even creates a caricatured likeness of King Francis the First.
  • SUBJECT MATTER: Holbein’s black humor cuts like a knife, satirizing and lampooning people familiar to his readers. The fantastic element is represented with Death personified as a skeleton and dramatic adventure is included with knights impaled by their lances and soldiers fighting for their lives with swords.
  • ECONOMICS: Woodcuts of religious themes were cheaply printed and sold as souvenirs to pilgrims to religious shrines, widely distributed and copied, and sold to both literate and semi-literate common people.


For further information on the history of cartooning, see…
PODCAST: A Broader View of the History of Cartooning


When you first started reading this article, I am sure you were wondering what a 16th century set of woodcuts have to do with animation. Well, they provide an excellent example of cartooning at its most basic. By studying Holbein’s technique using the material on the Animation Resources website, you will quickly see how the fundamentals of drawing are beautifully employed in these images.

I’ll leave it to you to take a look at these webpages and analyze the images in this e-book for the principles outlined.

Preston Blair’s “Advanced Animation”
In particular, look at line of action, facial expressions and movement of body masses in the characters in Holbein’s works.

Composition: How To Make Pictures
Apply the four elements of composition (picture area, depth, line and value) to Holbein’s woodcuts, especially the Bible cuts.


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


ABOUT THIS EDITION

In 1833, a scholar named Frances Douce partnered with the greatest engravers of the day, John and Mary Byfield and George Bonner to produce a definitive facsimile edition of Holbein’s “Dance of Death”. By this point, the original woodblocks had been long since lost to time, and the myriad of later recuts and imitations made it difficult to know which cuts were by Holbein and which were later copies. Douce spent many years examining surviving prints and fragments of woodblock books to compile a complete set, then Byfield and Bonner undertook making precise duplicates of the original wood blocks without the inevitable damage the original prints had suffered.

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
Leviticus X: Nadab and Abihu Overcome by Fire

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
First Chronicles X: The Overthrow and Death of Saul

Hans Holbein Dance of Death
Daniel III: Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego Cast Into The Fire

In 1858, Henry J. Bohn combined into a single volume Douce’s book and a reprint of Holbein’s Bible cuts, recreated by Byfield and Bonner in 1830. These careful copies after Holbein have pretty much replaced the surviving original woodcuts because of the poor condition of the nearly five hundred year old paper. Animation Resources has digitized these images from an extremely rare first edition of Bohn’s publication, and we are proud to bring them to you as a downloadable high resolution e-book. This PDF e-book is optimized for display on the iPad or printing two up with a cover on 8 1/2 by 11 inch paper.

REFPACK032: Hans Holbein’s Dance of Death
Download Page
Adobe PDF File / 161 Pages / 249 MB Download


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


Not A Member Yet? Want A Free Sample?

Check out this SAMPLE REFERENCE PACK! It will give you a taste of what Animation Resources members get to download every other month!

Sample RefPack


JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


FacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailFacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather
Share on Tumblr

Posted by Stephen Worth @ 11:41 am

May 7th, 2020

Members Click Here Membership Email Join Us!

Discord Discussions

Animation Resources Discord

Since we launched our Discord server yesterday, the place has been packed with creative artists from all over the globe. They’re sharing their work and networking and meeting lots of new people. One of the most exciting things about our server are the two channels dedicated to in-depth discussion: animation-talk and theory-talk. Animation-talk is for discussing films, and theory-talk is for analysis of technique.

Right now in theory-talk, Animation Resources own David “Pez” Hofmann is taking one of the breakdown clips that volunteer Nicholas Pozega prepares for our daily social media posts and he’s analyzing it, figuring out what makes it tick. The scene is from an Art Davis Warner Bros. cartoon called "Bye Bye Bluebeard" and it has very fast action that still reads clearly. Pez asked me to post the clip here so the folks in Discord can access it and still frame through it.

Here is the clip…And here is a download link so you can open the clip in Quicktime and still frame through it… Bye Bye Bluebeard Breakdown Clip

Every day, we post a breakdown clip on social media and people just look at it and say, "Hmmm. Interesting." But that isn’t what these are for. They’re for you to analyze and puzzle out so you can apply these techniques to your own work.

Jump into the Animation Resources Discord Server and join the discussion! For information on how to access our Discord server, see… Yesterday’s Post on the Discord Launch. Make sure you mark Saturday, May 30th at 4:30pm PDT on your calendar. That is when we are having our Discord Launch Party and you’re invited. Tell your friends!

FacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailFacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather
Share on Tumblr

Posted by Stephen Worth @ 10:55 am

April 30th, 2020

Members Click Here Membership Email Join Us!

RefPack033: Is It Possible To Learn From Even The Worst Cartoons?

Reference Pack

REFPACK 033
Download Page
Members Only Download

Every other month, members of Animation Resources are given access to an exclusive Members Only Reference Pack. These downloadable files are high resolution e-books on a variety of educational subjects and rare cartoons from the collection of Animation Resources in DVD quality. Our current Reference Pack has just been released. If you are a member, click through the link to access the MEMBERS ONLY DOWNLOAD PAGE. If you aren’t a member yet, please JOIN ANIMATION RESOURCES. It’s well worth it.


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


DVD QUALITY VIDEO:
Columbia Cartoons

Three Early Columbia Cartoons
"Scrappy’s Expedition" (1934) / "Railroad Rhythm" (1937) / "Happy Tots’ Expedition" (1940)

I want to make it clear from the outset that I don’t think these cartoons are very good from an entertainment standpoint. The gags aren’t particularly funny, the characters are devoid of personality, the stories don’t make a whole lot of sense, and they contain subject matter that ranges from completely obsolete to downright offensive. "Scrappy’s Expedition" features caricatures of radio stars that few people today will recognize. The Kate Smith caricature is accompanied by a song from 1917 that must have seemed out of date even in 1934 when the film was first released. There’s inappropriate sexual innuendo sprinkled in everywhere. A ship’s whistle behaves like a stereotypical gay man, and in "Happy Tots’ Expedition" the characters ride on a rocket in a blatantly phallic manner repeatedly sliding under other characters’ butts. "Railroad Rhythm" takes discomfort to a whole new level with stereotypical Eskimos rubbing noses and an incredibly insensitive caricature of character actor Steppin Fetchit as a chimpanzee… So why am I sharing these awful cartoons with our members?

Columbia Cartoons

Ancient pop culture trivia and long gone derogatory depictions of people from different races and cultures might be a subject for study by social scientists and historians, but they should hold no interest for film makers designing animation for modern audiences. The content of these old scratchy cartoons— specifically the gags, plots and characters— just don’t translate to our modern era. Creating cartoons like this today is a wrong-headed thing to do. But that doesn’t mean that there’s nothing to learn from these films, and it doesn’t mean that breaking them down and studying them is wrong.

Columbia Cartoons

A film maker sees films differently than audiences do. The audience expects to be entertained. A film maker is looking for techniques he can learn from. Even though these three cartoons are about as entertaining as watching paint dry, they do have value. There are some scenes that are brilliantly animated, particularly when it comes to the animation of rain, water and smoke; as well as the rendering of the scale and perspective of large vehicles like ships and trains.

In "Railroad Rhythm" still frame through the scene where the train dives under the tracks at 2:58. Notice how the train digs down in front in to avoid hitting the characters, while the momentum of the cars behind causes them to bunch up. The force from the rear drives the front of the train down into the dirt. As soon as the engine and coal car clear the scene into the hole, the animator creates a repeating cycle of passenger cars to save on pencil mileage, and turns his attention to the locomotive bursting through the tracks on the other side. The engine flexes like rubber back onto the rails and off screen, while incredibly well tracked layers of steam, rubble and railroad ties fly in all directions. Throughout all this, the characters tied to the track strain at the ropes holding them until the train clears the scene leaving a hole and rubble behind. This animation is every bit as complex as anything in a Mickey Mouse cartoon, and it’s even more amazing when you realize that the density of nitrate cels meant that all of this animation had to be accomplished on just three layers. Any way you slice it, it’s a brilliantly organized bit of animation.

Columbia Cartoons

"Happy Tots’ Expedition" was clearly intended to emulate the style of animation Disney created for "Snow White", but it does it in a totally bizarre way. Instead of "Squash and Stretch" and "Overlapping Action", the Columbia animators employ "Drag and Droop" and overlap the overlap until the characters wiggle like jello. It’s completely unprincipled— solid forms defining bone structure stretch like taffy, just like the soft fleshy jowls and chin wattles. At one point the animator misinterprets the King’s jowls as a mustache, and the ink & paint department dutifully corrects it by painting the mustache flesh colored. The King’s robe swirls around in random S curves like a cobra. Head and eye proportions change from frame to frame. Hook ups between scenes are sometimes totally wrong. Still frame through the scene at 3:18 with the cyclops take; or even worse, check out the drawings in the mustache scene at 4:39. The topper gag really does top everything that came before with one of the most obscene sequences ever to get past the Hayes Office.

As you still frame through this cartoon you’ll find a million hilarious drawings. But it’s hard to know whether it was supposed to be funny in that way or not. It might be a devastatingly sharp parody of Disney animation with extreme overlap, rubbery squash and stretch and butt joke after butt joke… or perhaps it’s a crew of inexperienced animators making a high splat on the wall. Either way, it’s worth taking a close look at and puzzling out what the animators might have intended. It might give you ideas for weird and unexpected ways of animating movement.

I hope you won’t dismiss old films because they don’t live up to modern tastes. As a film maker, you shouldn’t be studying films for their content. You should focus on how they were made. If you do that, even bad films can make you think and inspire you to go on and make much better films yourself.

Many thanks to Steve Stanchfield and Thunderbean Animation for sharing these rare films with our members.

REFPACK033: Scrappy’s Expedition (1934)
Download Page
MP4 Video File / SD / 6:47 / 125 MB Download

REFPACK033: Railroad Rhythm (1937)
Download Page
MP4 Video File / SD / 6:35 / 124 MB Download

REFPACK033: Happy Tots’ Expedition (1940)
Download Page
MP4 Video File / SD / 6:21 / 112 MB Download


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


Polish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish AnimationPolish Animation


MEMBERS LOGIN To Download Video

JOIN TODAY To Access Members Only Content


Not A Member Yet? Want A Free Sample?

Check out this SAMPLE REFERENCE PACK! It will give you a taste of what Animation Resources members get to download every other month!

Sample RefPack

FacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailFacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather
Share on Tumblr

Posted by Stephen Worth @ 11:38 am